Shingles vs Nails

Are you aware of the difference between sheathing and shingles? Both of these materials are very beneficial when it comes to the roof of a house. Also, do you know what the nailing method is better for your roof? Hand nailing or a nail gun? Our experts at My Florida Roofing Contractor is here to clear up the air. We are one of the top roofing companies in Vero Beach.


What Material Are You Using?

When you are getting a new roof installed, it is silly to think about how exactly the roof will be nailed down. However, it is important to consider what is best when yielding your roof. However, the answer to this question is not merely because both have their own disadvantages and advantages. It is important to determine the correct answer on a roof to roof basis instead of the installer preference. You must consider the factors with each material:

  • Type of Roof Sheathing
  • Type of Shingles
  • Experience and Quality of the Installer


Nail Gun or Hand Nailing?

First, you must consider the many factors of both sheathing and shingles. This will aid your decision. Trust one of the best roofing companies. Here are the factors:

  • Roof Sheathing
    • The type of sheathing and condition of the wood deck are essential factors in determining how a new roof system should be fastened to the sheathing. After an old roof system is removed, our roofing contractor will inspect the roof deck to determine if the sheathing is in good condition or if any of it should be replaced. Damaged wood will not be able to accept a nail driven with a hammer or a nail gun. After all damaged wood is replaced, the deck should be inspected for gaps in the sheathing that a nail could potentially be driven into.
    • Problems can occur if a nail gun is used on the house with a significant amount of gaps in the roof sheathing. If a nail from a nail gun is lodged between the planks, the shingle will not be properly fastened. It is impossible to see if a nail hits solid wood since the roof deck is covered by felt paper. Hand nail installers are quick to ‘feel’ a nail miss the wood sheathing while nail gun operators have to rely on sounds and intuition. A good contractor will inspect the roof sheathing after it is removed to determine if nail misses are likely to occur. If this is the case, hand nailing should be preferred over the use of a nail gun.


  • Types of Shingles
    • Standard shingles
      • Needs to be hand nailed. This will require six nails per shingle to achieve a wind rating of 130 mph. However, increasing the number of fasteners per shingle also increases the number of deck penetrations. More penetrations into the roof deck will weaken the shingles over time due to thermal expansion and contraction. Also, there is a greater chance for nails to blow through shingles from a nail gun if they are not engineered with the SureNail strip.
    • Premium shingles
      • Does not require hand nailing. Material costs are less on standard shingles but will require more labor if they are hand nailed. Installing a high-quality shingle adds customer value in many different ways. Using a premium shingle eliminates the need to question the fastening pattern, minimizes the number of deck penetrations, and maximizes the wind resistance.

Call Us Today

Our contractors know what type of nailing method your roof needs. There is a big difference between using a nail gun and hand nailing. We are one of the greatest roofing companies in Vero Beach. My Florida Roofing Contractor, which was formerly known as Reyes Group General Construction, was established in 2003. My Florida Roofing Contractor is committed to using quality products, providing excellent service, and delivering the best customer care possible. We provide all clients with a warranty for all completed projects. Please give us a call today and see for yourself.  We are the best roofing company near me.

Book your Free Estimate

There's no reason to wait – get a professional roof estimate, understand your options and make an informed decision!

"*" indicates required fields

Los Dos fishing teamLos Dos fishing team

My Florida roofing is an amazing company to deal with. The recently redid our roof from shingles to standing seem metal roof. It looks amazing. I got roughly about 10 quotes from the top roofers in Indian river county and they help educate me and showed me different options of material's for the new roof. Their team came in and stripped reroof the entire home in about week to do great weather. They strip and relapse before any rain could hit the exposed material. Rene and Maxine are such a pleasure to deal with. The are very upfront about everything and every detail that you speak with Rene about is backed up with written documentation so you know and see exactly what you are paying for. They also show and explain the different options to add on if you choose to. They are very quick to respond and answer any questions you may have in a timely matter. No doubt in my mind did I make the right decision going with My Florida Roofing. I recommend and would you use them again for any future projects. Again thank you Rene, Maxine and all of the team at My Florida Roofing for making a new roof process so quick and painless

Ren RobbRen Robb

The Reyes' were very friendly, accommodating and professional. Rene visited the site often to check on the work. The crew was professional friendly and efficient. We had our roof replaced, asphalt shingles to metal, almost a year ago now and still marvel at the look. The color matches perfectly with the house trim. I highly recommend MyFloridaRoofing.

Your Roof Is Our Passion.
Let Us Assist You With Your Next Roofing Project.

Call Us Today!
(772) 218-5288

Family Owned & Operated
for Over 20 Years.

Contact Us Now

Related Posts

an asphalt shingle roof that insurance may ask to be replaced with a new one
Roof Replacement

Apparently I Need a New Roof

Insurance Is Requiring a New Roof for Many Florida Homeowners. Here’s What You Should Know At installation, most new residential roofs have an expected lifespan of at least 15 years,

Read More »

Your Roof is Our Passion. Let Us Assist with Your Next Roofing Project.

Family Owned & Operated for Over 15 Years. Call Us Today! (772) 206-4506